Yeah, I get that the past isn’t what it used to be, but.
Rally ’round, children. Aunt Mirabella is going to tell you a story, and I’m only going to say it once.
Once upon a time, when fandom was shiny and new and bright rivers of porn ran sparkling through the kingdom, all of Fandomland was… well, pretty much the same wind tunnel of wank and pissiness that it is now, actually; but there was one great Law, my children, written in the stars above Fandomland for everyone to see and take heed of, and that Law was this:
What goes on in fandom stays in fandom.
That meant that if you got pissed off at someone for flaming you, you didn’t track down their employer and rat them out for writing NC-17 Thundercats porn. If you met a fellow fan’s family, you didn’t blurt out “You know, she writes the hottest buttsex I have ever been privileged to witness” to her 90-year-old grandmother. And you never, ever, ever pointed the mainstream media in a fellow fan’s direction unless you knew with cast-iron certainty that she was okay with it.
You see, back in the day, people understood that the non-fannish world, which in fact is most of the world, is a cold and uptight place, especially if you happen to be American. They understood that fanfiction was something people lost their jobs over, and that an awful lot of people in fandom need those jobs for silly things like feeding their kids. They understood, simply as a matter of courtesy, that not everyone wants media attention, that sometimes people just want to hang out in that by-fans-for-fans space and it will be just peachy with them if Steven Colbert never discovers their existence.
I don’t know where that understanding went. All I know is that fandom seems to be increasingly full of people who literally cannot conceive of there being anyone in the world who does not want media attention of any sort. Maybe you can blame reality TV. I don’t know. All I know is that I’m about fucking tired of having to pull down parts of my site because the “What goes on in fandom stays in fandom” rule has gone the way of men’s fedoras.
So let me make this clear: you do not ever, ever have my permission to link to my site or my fic in any non-fandom venue. When I find out you have, and I will because it will show up in my site stats, I will pull down whatever you linked to, and everyone you linked and everyone else who wanted to read that fic will be shit out of luck. If this means pulling down my entire site until the hits from your link go away, I’ll do that too.
Look. Don’t be an asshole, even unwittingly. I understand that people exist who can’t comprehend not wanting to be on The Real World. I’m asking you to understand that people exist who can’t comprehend wanting to.
What goes on in fandom stays in fandom. Live it. We’ll all be happier and I can leave my goddamned pages up.
June 13th, 2007 at 12:08 am
Hi, I just drop in here to thank you for your fantastic fic: He Shadow of His Wings. I’ve searched Harry/Draco fanfiction at google yesterday and I found your site. I stayed up all night reading it. I think I can wait forever for your update. Thank you again. I’m nodding and I need my beautiful sleep now.
October 17th, 2007 at 6:44 am
I saw this entry a few days ago, nodded sagely at every criticism and was generally pleased that someone had bloodly well come out and said it.
Then I toodled off to write a complimentary e-mail to the author of a particularly good fanfiction. When I finally found her e-mail address, I was also shocked to discover that the story (RPS, in this case) is being released in paperback next month. Of course the names are changed and I’m sure the plot was tweaked to match, but that didn’t bother me so much.
I got to thinking about your blog again, and decided that it goes one step further: fanfiction itself should stay in fanfiction. I’ve known plenty of Internet authors who’ve gone on to put their talents on pulp and that’s just peachy - they write orignal stories and often continue with their guilty pleasures on the side. Taking a completed work, however, and reworking it into something -marketable- diminishes it. This isn’t moulding a book into another medium (though screenplays, too, are often done ham-handedly); this is trading the pride you feel in completing an exceptional piece of work for your name on a book jacket.
Long story short: I’m in your camp.
November 8th, 2007 at 9:49 am
I say amen.
Fandom used to be a place where I would escape bigotry and suffocating self-righteousness encountered too much in RL. (it really doesn’t matter whether you’re American or Indonesian- like me)
my fandom though, is sometimes so full of negative energy I wonder what the hell I’m doing staying there. But there are stuff worth sticking around for.
Stuff like your stories, and this peaceful little haven I fall behind whenever I feel salty - http://we-are-cities.livejournal.com/tag/prompts
I hope people would be more considerate towards you and your wishes in the future~~ I don’t want to lose my favorite story-teller (no, seriously)
*glares at fandom*
November 19th, 2007 at 8:30 pm
Um…I just thought I’d give you a head’s up that I recommended your fic (Shadow of His Wings) on my Fanfiction.net account page. I hope that’s okay. If it’s not, just let me know and I’ll take it down right away. X]
Thanks. And I absolutely adore your story.